Login
Youth Truth Home
Contact Us
Twitter
LinkedIn
YouTube
  • Home
    • Our Impact
    • How We Work
  • Products & Services
    • Student Surveys
    • Family & Staff Surveys
    • Online Reports
    • Professional Development
  • Get Started
    • RSVP for a Webinar
    • Registration
  • Resources
    • Insights From the Student Experience: Emotional & Mental Health
    • Students Weigh In: Learning & Well-Being During COVID-19
    • Learning From Student and Stakeholder Voice
    • Guidebooks & Videos
    • Success Stories
    • Research
  • About
    • Team
    • Careers
    • Advisory Board
    • Funders
    • History
  • News
  • Contact

Rethinking What Constitutes Impact

March 30, 2021Jay KustkaYT in the News

By Phil Buchanan, Sonya Kendall Heisters, and Jen Vorse Wilka

Foundations and individual donors need to reconceive impact in a way that puts hearing firsthand the experiences of those they seek to help front and center.

If any area illustrates this point, it is education. After all, listening to students should not be a radical idea — especially now, with more young people enduring depression, stress, and anxiety.

But it certainly felt like a radical idea back in 2008, when Fay Twersky (then of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation and now president of the Arthur M. Blank Family Foundation), Valerie Threlfall (now president of Ekouté consulting), and one of us (CEP President Phil Buchanan) were seeking support for the idea of YouthTruth, a national student survey designed to provide actionable feedback to school and district leaders. Critic after critic, including many at foundations from which we were seeking support, pushed back on the very idea that a mechanism to listen to the candid perspectives of young people was valuable.

While some funders did step up with significant support, the challenge more often than not was for us to prove that student perceptions were linked to some objective measure of “impact” or student “outcomes,” which at that time usually meant test scores. One foundation leader we pitched said that he thought student perceptions were “orthogonal” to impact, which caused Phil to surreptitiously look up the word on his phone and then recognize the meeting was not going well.

To that leader’s credit, he and the foundation he led ultimately became supporters of YouthTruth. But his initial resistance typified a perspective that still today remains too prevalent across areas of philanthropic work: a perspective that denies the voice and even the legitimacy of the very people we should care about the most — the people we seek to help.

Tags: cep, Jen Wilka, News, Phil Buchanan, Sonya Heisters

Related Articles

New California Accountability System Signals Progress- YouthTruth’s Sonya Heisters in Education Week

September 28, 2016ytadmin

YouthTruth Convenes Advisory Board

August 16, 2016ytadmin

YouthTruth Executive Director Blogs for Education Week

April 28, 2016ytadmin

415-286-9538   hello@youthtruthsurvey.org

131 Steuart Street, Suite 501      San Francisco, CA 94105